AI in learning and development (L&D) isn’t new. For years, we have seen organizations embrace automation tools, chatbots, and recommendation engines under the umbrella of “AI in learning.” And yes, those technologies brought efficiency and scale.

But here’s the truth: not all AI is created equal.

There’s a new wave emerging: one that is not just technological, but deeply pedagogical. It is ushering in a shift from content delivery to active, adaptive coaching and from automation to autonomy.

This is the world of Agentic AI and the momentum is real: it is projected to power 33% of enterprise software applications by 2028, up from just 1% in 2024, as per a Gartner study.

In this blog, I will try to unpack the difference between Agentic AI and traditional AI, and why this distinction matters more than ever if we want learning to truly translate into performance.

Also Read: Using Agentic AI to Power Skill-Based Learning Paths in Your LXP

Over the past decade, AI has quietly reshaped many backend processes in L&D by automating course curation, adding intelligent search and nudges, refining learning analytics and so much more.

But most of this has been traditional AI in learning, that is, structured, rules-based systems that operate within narrow boundaries. These systems can recommend, retrieve, and respond. What they can’t do is coach, adapt, or evolve with the learner.

That’s where Agentic AI coaching changes the game.

Agentic AI is built around AI agents which are autonomous, interactive systems that simulate real-world scenarios, make decisions, and evolve through learner interaction. They don’t just give the right answer; they ask the right questions.

In a world where performance matters more than completion rates, where behavior change is the holy grail, this new form of learning with AI agents is building impact we have long aspired to but rarely achieved.

Let’s take a closer look at traditional AI in learning.

Most conventional learning platforms that claim to use AI rely on content tagging, user profiling, and recommendation algorithms. In other words, they help you find what to learn, but not necessarily how to learn it, or more importantly, how to apply it.

Content-based AI systems can:

• Serve curated content based on a role or skill
• Push reminders or nudges
• Auto-generate quiz questions

But they often fall short when it comes to contextual understanding, emotional intelligence, and real-time adaptability. These are the exact traits required to develop behavioral skills like communication, decision-making, leadership, and empathy.

And these limitations are becoming more pronounced as organizations demand deeper outcomes from L&D, not just consumption, but capability. In other words, AI limitations in L&D are no longer theoretical. They have become business-critical.

So, what is Agentic AI and why is it different?

Imagine an AI agent that doesn’t just serve content, but steps into the learning experience as a virtual coach, a role-play partner, or a decision-making scenario simulator.

That’s the core of Agentic AI coaching.

These agents have autonomy—the ability to act independently, not just respond to prompts. They can simulate human conversation, read context, respond dynamically, and provide feedback, all while learning from the learner.

Some examples of how you can leverage interactive learning with Agentic AI:

• Your teams can practice difficult customer conversations in a safe environment
• They can navigate ethical dilemmas or leadership challenges with branching outcomes
• They can receive coaching on tone, decision quality, and body language in real-time

Unlike static systems, AI agent skill development adapts to each learner’s pace, progress, and decision patterns while creating personalized, evolving learning journeys.

And this is where transformation begins.

Download our eBook – Agentic AI & the Future of Upskilling A Hands-On Playbook for Talent Transformation

The question that matters most: does this kind of AI actually improve outcomes?

The data as well as learner feedback say yes.

With Agentic AI in workplace learning, we have seen:

Higher engagement: Learners spend more time when they are not just watching or reading, but interacting.

Faster application: Role-play and simulation accelerates the transfer of learning from training rooms to the real world.

Improved confidence: Practicing with AI agents allows learners to build muscle memory, make mistakes safely, and build readiness for high-stakes roles.

Better behavioral change: Especially in areas like leadership, negotiation, and customer service where skill is as much about nuance as it is about knowledge.

Across clients, AI-driven learning outcomes are consistently outperforming traditional eLearning in areas like retention, feedback scores, and time-to-competence.

In short: skill development with AI agents is proving to be the missing link between knowledge and performance.

So how do you know when to use agentic AI vs traditional AI?

The short answer: they serve different purposes.

For instance, you can use content-based AI systems for efficiency—cataloging, tagging, nudging, and content discovery. But when your goal is capability building, especially in complex, human-centric roles, Agentic AI is where the value is.

Here’s when to prioritize it:

• Behavioral transformation initiatives
• Leadership development and team communication programs
• Customer-facing roles where tone, empathy, and agility matter
• High-stakes environments where decisions have real consequences
• Onboarding and practice for frontline employees with dynamic scenarios

And most importantly, it is not an either/or. We often see the best results when AI coaching vs automation isn’t framed as a binary choice, but as a layered approach, where content is foundational and Agentic AI brings it to life.

Here’s the thing: most organizations don’t lack content. They lack conversion.

The gap between what employees know and what they do on the job has only widened. Traditional AI helped us scale knowledge. But it’s Agentic AI learning that helps us scale capability.

More than the next chapter for L&D, Agentic AI is a new paradigm, where learners engage, perform, and apply skills in job-like settings and impact is measured in outcomes, not just dashboards.

The future of L&D lies in systems that can adapt, interact, and elevate human potential, not replace it.

At Enthral, we believe AI for workforce development should be grounded in empathy, intelligence, and continuous feedback loops. That’s why we have invested deeply in building Agentic AI capabilities that don’t just check boxes, but change lives.

If your skilling strategy needs to evolve from compliance to competence, from knowledge to performance, it may be time to explore what Agentic AI can unlock for your teams.

Interested in seeing how Enthral’s AI agents work in real-world learning scenarios?

www.enthral.ai